Spiritual Evidence Map
← Sources
Philosophy referenceprimarycontextVerified

The Concept of Religion

Kevin Schilbrack · 2022 · Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Spiritual Evidence Map/Last updated May 10, 2026/Claims v1.0.0-provisional/Sources v1.0.0/Scores provisional
Citation dossier

This source is used as context evidence across 10 linked claims and 8 related evidence hubs. Its citation record is marked verified; that verifies the source trail, not the truth of any linked claim.

Source type
Philosophy reference
Map role
context
Claim links
10
Direct access
Recorded

Summary

Explores how philosophers and scholars define the category of religion, including belief, practice, community, ritual, transcendence, and family-resemblance approaches.

How this source is used on the map

Useful background for claims involving God, religious figures, or traditions because it clarifies what counts as a religious claim before evidence is weighed.

Citation record

Authors
Kevin Schilbrack
Year
2022
Publication
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Source type
Philosophy reference
Map role
context
Credibility level
primary
Citation status
Verified
DOI
Not recorded
PubMed
Not recorded
PDF
Not recorded

Linked claims

Evidence score 2/10
Angels — superhuman benevolent intermediary beings

A central concept across the Abrahamic religions and beyond, with personal-encounter reports throughout history. Direct evidence essentially zero; the modern guardian-angel and angel-number reading is the weakest part.

Evidence score 1/10
Demons — superhuman malevolent intermediary beings

Cross-tradition belief with no direct evidence. Possession, oppression and 'demonic attack' phenomena map cleanly onto sleep paralysis, dissociation, psychosis, and post-traumatic states.

Evidence score 6/10
Enlightenment / awakening

Buddhist bodhi, Hindu moksha, Christian unitive states, Sufi fana — a remarkably consistent endpoint described across traditions, with growing neuroscience confirmation. The 'what it actually is' is the open question.

Evidence score 2/10
Exorcism — ritual expulsion of demonic possession

Possession states are real and widely reported. Standard psychiatry maps them onto dissociative, psychotic, and culturally-shaped trance phenomena; modern exorcism deaths are well-documented.

Evidence score 2/10
Heaven — a postmortem realm of the saved or righteous

A near-universal religious claim with massive cultural footprint and zero empirical evidence. Sits downstream of theism and survival-after-death — its plausibility tracks theirs.

Evidence score 1/10
Hell — a postmortem realm of the damned

Massively documented in tradition, zero direct evidence, and substantial harm record from belief — eternal-torment doctrines have warped lives for centuries.

Evidence score 2/10
Miracles — divine suspensions of natural law

Reported across every religious tradition. A small number of well-documented unexplained cures (Lourdes Medical Bureau) survive scrutiny; the inference to 'divine action' is a separate, much larger step.

Evidence score 3/10
Pantheism — the universe is divine

The view that the universe and God are identical — divinity is not separate from nature but is nature itself, in its totality.

Evidence score 1/10
The Devil / Satan — a personal force of evil

The claim that a literal, personal adversary — Satan, Iblis, Mara, Ahriman — is an active intelligent force behind evil and temptation, considered here at the generic level rather than within any specific tradition.

Evidence score 4/10
God / Theism

The claim that a personal, conscious deity created and continues to engage with the universe — considered here at the generic level rather than within any specific tradition.

Related evidence hubs

Related sources