Meta-analysis that conceals more than it reveals: Comment on Storm et al. (2010)
Ray Hyman · 2010 · Psychological Bulletin, 136(4), 486–490
This source is used as challenges evidence across 3 linked claims and 2 related evidence hubs. Its citation record is marked verified; that verifies the source trail, not the truth of any linked claim.
Summary
Methodological critique of Storm, Tressoldi & Di Risio (2010), arguing the meta-analytic effect dissolves under stricter inclusion criteria.
How this source is used on the map
Pairs directly with the Storm et al. meta-analysis — the classic skeptical reply in the same journal issue.
Citation record
- Authors
- Ray Hyman
- Year
- 2010
- Publication
- Psychological Bulletin, 136(4), 486–490
- Source type
- Skeptical analysis
- Map role
- challenges
- Credibility level
- primary
- Citation status
- Verified
- DOI
- 10.1037/a0019676
- PubMed
- Not recorded
- Not recorded
Linked claims
Often subsumed under remote viewing in modern parapsychology. As an everyday claim, very poorly supported.
The CIA's declassified Stargate program ran for two decades and reported above-chance results. The official 1995 review judged the operational utility insufficient.
Decades of ganzfeld and card studies report small effects at meta-analytic level. Critics argue methodological flaws explain them.
Related evidence hubs
Related research reports
Related sources
Major reference for the sceptical / cognitive-explanation side of psi-style claims.
The classic skeptical replication counterpoint to Bem and Honorton, useful for keeping ganzfeld pages from presenting a one-sided meta-analytic story.
Essential counterweight to Utts' positive assessment of the Stargate / remote-viewing evidence; the two reports should be read together.
One of the strongest pro-psi statistical summaries published in a mainstream APA journal.
Core pro-remote-viewing evaluation from the Stargate review period; should be paired with Hyman's evaluation to show the interpretive split.
A central pro-psi anchor for ganzfeld/free-response claims, especially telepathy-style information transfer under sensory-reduction conditions.