Spiritual Evidence Map
← Sources
Philosophy referenceprimarycontextVerified

Consciousness

Robert Van Gulick · 2022 · Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Spiritual Evidence Map/Last updated May 10, 2026/Claims v1.0.0-provisional/Sources v1.0.0/Scores provisional
Citation dossier

This source is used as context evidence across 8 linked claims and 5 related evidence hubs. Its citation record is marked verified; that verifies the source trail, not the truth of any linked claim.

Source type
Philosophy reference
Map role
context
Claim links
8
Direct access
Recorded

Summary

Survey of the philosophy of consciousness covering the main theories and the explanatory gap.

How this source is used on the map

Pulls together the conceptual frameworks behind every empirical claim about consciousness.

Citation record

Authors
Robert Van Gulick
Year
2022
Publication
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Source type
Philosophy reference
Map role
context
Credibility level
primary
Citation status
Verified
DOI
Not recorded
PubMed
Not recorded
PDF
Not recorded

Linked claims

Evidence score 3/10
AI systems can be conscious

Behaviour is not evidence of inner experience. We have no detector for consciousness in any system we did not already believe to be conscious.

Evidence score 4/10
The brain may filter or receive consciousness

The brain as transducer, not source — proposed by James, Bergson, Huxley. Compatible with neural correlates but harder to falsify.

Evidence score 2/10
The universe is conscious

The view that the universe as a whole is conscious — sometimes called cosmopsychism. Distinct from panpsychism (which puts mind in atomic matter) and from idealism (which says reality is mental).

Evidence score 7/10
Consciousness is produced by the brain (materialism)

The materialist / physicalist view: lesions, drugs, anesthesia, and imaging all show tight brain–mind coupling, and physical mechanism explains an enormous range of phenomena. Why neural activity feels like anything at all remains the open exception.

Evidence score 5/10
Consciousness is fundamental

If consciousness is basic, the 'hard problem' dissolves. The cost is a major break with the standard physicalist picture.

Evidence score 3/10
Idealism — reality is mental

From Berkeley to Kastrup: matter is appearance within a more fundamental mind. Coherent, ancient, contested.

Evidence score 3/10
Mind-body dualism

Descartes' view that mind and body are two distinct substances that somehow interact. The most intuitive position; also the one neuroscience has worked hardest to discredit.

Evidence score 4/10
Panpsychism

If basic matter has a hint of experience, complex brains can build complex minds. The 'combination problem' is the catch.

Related evidence hubs

Related research reports

Related sources